The deal score
How we decide a car is a deal
A deal score is a single number from 0 to 100. It answers one question - is this a genuinely good buy? - and nothing else. It is not a measure of whether a car is cool, fast, rare or the one you happen to want. Those are things you filter for; they are never a reason for us to call a listing a better deal than the numbers support.
Here is every factor, exactly as it is weighted right now. The weights add up to 100.0.
| Factor | Weight |
|---|---|
| Below market (asking prices) How far below the going rate this car is priced. We fit a price-versus-mileage curve to clean comparable listings of the same exact specification and model year, then measure the gap between this asking price and that curve. | 28 |
| Below real sold prices How the price compares with what cars like it have ACTUALLY SOLD for at auction - the real money that changed hands, including the buyer's fee - not what sellers were asking. We only use this where genuine sale data exists, so it is blank for most cars. | 14 |
| Motivated seller How long the seller has been trying to sell - measured against what is normal FOR THAT EXACT CAR, not against a flat number of days. A Ferrari 458 that has been listed 60 days is moving at its usual pace; a Tesla Model Y listed 60 days has sat four times longer than its peers. We count the true total time on the market across every re-listing, so pulling the ad and re-posting it fresh does not buy a clean slate, and we add how many times it has been re-listed. A long-listed car scores a bonus; a car that has just come up is simply neutral and is never marked down for being new. | 14 |
| Value retention (per mile) How quickly this car loses value AS MILES ADD UP - the steepness of its price-versus-mileage curve over the next 30,000 miles. A flat curve means the miles you drive cost you little. A car already priced below the curve gets credit for that cushion: it holds its price until driving brings the market down to what you paid. | 12 |
| Vehicle history What the listing sites report about accidents, salvage or flood titles, and previous owners, and how many separate sources agree. A reported problem counts strongly against the score. This is a screening signal from listing badges, not a verified history report - always buy the full report before you commit. | 12 |
| Comparison confidence How much the comparison itself can be trusted: how many clean comparable listings the price curve is built from, and how tightly they fit it. A deal measured against 200 close comparisons is worth more than the same number measured against 11 scattered ones. | 10 |
| Mileage vs typical Where the odometer sits against what is normal for that car's age and model - not simply low miles. Well under typical is a bonus, well over is a penalty, and anything within about a quarter of typical is treated as neutral. | 6 |
| Year-over-year resilience How well the car holds value over TIME at the same mileage - the age side of depreciation, as opposed to the mileage side measured by value retention. We read the same specification one model year older at the same mileage and see how much the extra year of age costs. Example: a 2016 F-TYPE R Coupe at 20,500 miles sits at $50,000 while the identical 2015 at the same 20,500 miles asks $49,800 - a year of age costs only $200, which is very strong. We never compare across a model redesign. | 4 |
Measured, but not counted yet
We track these two and show them on a car's breakdown, but they carry no weight in today's score. Both need a long run of week-by-week data before we would trust them to move a number that people act on, and we would rather leave a factor at zero than let a thin signal tip a car into your inbox.
| Price-drop velocity How hard and how fast the asking price has already been cut during this listing, as a monthly rate. A seller actively dropping the price is moving toward a deal. | 0 |
| Market strength / supply Whether this exact specification is tight or oversupplied - how many comparable cars are listed right now, and whether that number has been rising or falling. A tight market means a good one is hard to replace; a crowded one means the next car along may be cheaper. | 0 |
Everything is judged against cars like it
None of these factors uses a fixed threshold. A price, a mileage reading and a number of days on the market only mean something next to the same specification and model year: the same trim, the same engine, the same transmission. A Ferrari that has been listed two months is selling at its normal pace; a mainstream SUV listed two months has sat far longer than its peers. Where a specification is too rare for a reliable figure of its own, we step up to the next broadest sensible group - and we say which one we used.
Two factors that sound alike
Value retention and year-over-year resilience are both about losing value, but they measure different halves of it.
- Value retention is about MILES. Drive 10,000 miles - what does that cost you? That is the slope of the car's price curve.
- Year-over-year resilience is about TIME. Park the car and add no miles at all - what does a year of age cost you? We read the same specification one model year older at the same mileage. For example: a 2016 F-TYPE R Coupe at 20,500 miles sits at $50,000, and the identical 2015 car at the same 20,500 miles asks $49,800. A whole year of age costs $200. That is a car that holds its value through time.
A car can be strong on one and weak on the other, which is why we score them separately.
How the number is put together
Each factor is scored from 0 to 100 on its own fixed scale, so a 90 means the same thing on a $30,000 sedan as on a $300,000 supercar. The score is the weighted average of those factors. If something cannot be measured for a particular car - no real sale data, no mileage, too few comparable listings - that factor is left out and the remaining weights are re-spread. We never substitute a neutral guess for a missing measurement, and we show you how much of the score we were actually able to measure.
Two factors behave a little differently, on purpose. Motivated seller can only ever help a car: a listing that has just come up is simply neutral, never marked down for being new. Mileage vs typical works in both directions, because unusually high miles is real information, not a missing one.
A car with fewer than three clean comparable listings gets no score at all. There is nothing honest to compare it with, so we say so instead of inventing a number.
What the score is not
- It is not a condition report. We have never seen the car.
- It is not a verified history check. The history factor reads what listing sites report - buy the full report before you commit.
- It is not a promise about the future. It describes today's market, measured from today's listings and real sales.
- A price far below everything else is flagged for verification rather than celebrated. Sometimes it is a typo, sometimes the car has a reason to be cheap. We tell you to check.
Weights last changed 2026-11-10. When we change them we say so - a score that moves should be the market moving, not us quietly moving the goalposts.